A Risk Sciences International Case Study

Risk-Based Decision Making (RBDM) Compliance and Enforcement

RBDM compliance and enforcement

Client: Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED)

Listing of the client in no way affirms the client's support, sponsorship, or validation in any form of Risk Sciences International or the RSI staff member(s) who conducted this project during their stay with RSI or prior to joining the company. This case study is displayed for informative purposes only to demonstrate the capacity of RSI staff members. This case study reveals no proprietary information or information deemed sensitive.

Project description:

Risk-Based Decision Making (RBDM) Compliance and Enforcement

Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED), through its Spectrum Management Innovation Directorate, sought support in applying risk-based decision making (RBDM) across its compliance and enforcement responsibilities. The department was looking for a structured and data-driven approach to prioritize regulatory actions in a way that reflects risks to the public interest.

To this end, RSI was asked to provide expert guidance on key elements of an RBDM framework. ISED requested support in developing a shared risk lexicon and detailed taxonomies covering hazards, harms, and control measures relevant to telecommunications regulation. These foundational elements were intended to enable consistent characterization and comparison of risks within the department’s mandate.

ISED also requested assistance in identifying appropriate methods for risk measurement and estimation, with the goal of building internal capacity to assess and visualize diverse public risks. They sought illustrative examples and guidance materials that could be used for training and internal alignment. In addition, the department asked for support in drafting a data structure capable of linking risk elements with control strategies and cost considerations, even in cases where operational data may be incomplete.

The work was to inform a scalable framework that would enable ISED to make more transparent and evidence-informed decisions across its regulatory functions.

Start: 2021

End: 2022

Experts related to this case study

Greg Paoli

CEO, Principal Risk Scientist

Greg Paoli is the CEO and Principal Risk Scientist at Risk Sciences International (RSI), a firm he co-founded in 2006 following the integration of his earlier consultancy, Decisionalysis Risk Consultants, with the consulting activities of the McLaughlin Centre for Population...
Read More about Greg Paoli

Todd Ruthman

Vice-President Software and Modelling Solutions

Todd Ruthman serves as Vice‑President, Software and Modelling Solutions at Risk Sciences International (RSI) and has been with RSI since its founding in 2006. With a BASc in Systems Design Engineering from the University of Waterloo, Todd strives to understand the...
Read More about Todd Ruthman

More RSI Case Studies

RSI presents a very small selection of case studies to highlight some of its key work.

Evaluation of Toxicological Data on Experior

To support the evaluation of a new veterinary pharmaceutical product intended for use in bovines, a scientific review was requested of submitted toxicological data related to the active compound LY488756. This compound, proposed under the product name Experior, had been...
Read More about Evaluation of Toxicological Data on Experior

Finalization of Risk Assessment on Secure Opioid Dispensing Devices

To support decision-making around modifications to opioid agonist treatment delivery, a detailed risk assessment was requested to evaluate the integration of secure dispensing devices for direct patient access to hydromorphone. Building on a previously conducted preliminary assessment, the work required...
Read More about Finalization of Risk Assessment on Secure Opioid Dispensing Devices

External Peer Consultation of the Inorganic – Late Biomonitoring Approach Draft Screening Assessment Report

To support the Chemicals Management Plan under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA), Health Canada sought expert peer consultation for a draft screening assessment report (DSAR) evaluating 47 inorganic substances identified as priorities. The client required independent scientific and technical...
Read More about External Peer Consultation of the Inorganic – Late Biomonitoring Approach Draft Screening Assessment Report

Risk-Based Optimization of Enforcement Activities

A federal agency required scientific support to enhance the effectiveness of its environmental enforcement activities. This involved identifying and analyzing the risk factors—both environmental and human health-related—that contribute to the likelihood and impact of regulatory offences. The objective was to...
Read More about Risk-Based Optimization of Enforcement Activities

Characterizing uncertainty in MAF values estimated using the KEMI MAF

The client sought to improve understanding of uncertainties surrounding the application of mixture assessment factors (MAFs) for aquatic receptors, specifically those estimated using the KEMI methodology. While the KEMI MAF approach is considered technically robust, its assumptions—particularly about chemical-specific controls,...
Read More about Characterizing uncertainty in MAF values estimated using the KEMI MAF

Update of WHO Guidance on Food Defense

To support international efforts in mitigating deliberate threats to the food system, the World Health Organization commissioned an update to its earlier guidance titled Terrorist Threats to Food. The revision aimed to broaden the original scope by addressing not only...
Read More about Update of WHO Guidance on Food Defense

Development of a National Food Safety Information System and Risk Assessment Capacity in Vietnam

Authorities in Vietnam sought targeted expertise to strengthen the country’s ability to detect, assess, and respond to food safety threats. This initiative had two linked objectives: building a comprehensive, transparent, and reliable national food safety information system, and enhancing risk...
Read More about Development of a National Food Safety Information System and Risk Assessment Capacity in Vietnam

Risk-Based Decision-Making (RBDM) Support for Plasma Supply / Sufficiency

Facing renewed challenges in securing a reliable domestic plasma supply, Canadian Blood Services sought support to apply a Risk-Based Decision-Making (RBDM) framework. The objective was to assess the value and implications of expanding domestic plasma collection and processing capacity in...
Read More about Risk-Based Decision-Making (RBDM) Support for Plasma Supply / Sufficiency

Expansion of the Stochastic Health Canada Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment Tool

Health Canada sought to enhance its Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment (QMRA) tool, originally developed over 15 years ago for stakeholders responsible for drinking water systems. With advancements in probabilistic modeling and microbial risk assessment, the client required updates to reflect...
Read More about Expansion of the Stochastic Health Canada Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment Tool

Contraceptive recall review

Health Canada requested an external review following significant public criticism of its handling of a pharmaceutical recall. The case involved a contraceptive drug that was withdrawn due to packaging errors, and the department faced questions about whether it had acted...
Read More about Contraceptive recall review

Communication material on lithium in drinking water and health risks

To support public communication around emerging drinking water concerns, RSI was engaged to develop accessible, scientifically grounded materials on lithium exposure and its potential health effects. The work focused on equipping stakeholders with clear, credible information that could inform both...
Read More about Communication material on lithium in drinking water and health risks

Analysis in Support of Risk-Based Decision-Making for the Alberta Safety Codes Council

An independent regulatory organization responsible for oversight of Alberta’s safety codes system sought to strengthen its capacity for risk-based decision-making. The organization aimed to ensure that regulatory actions—particularly in the area of petroleum storage tanks—were guided by clear, evidence-based prioritization...
Read More about Analysis in Support of Risk-Based Decision-Making for the Alberta Safety Codes Council

Environmental Health Factors, Chronic Diseases, and Pandemic Resilience

To support more effective health policy and pandemic preparedness, this project examined how environmental health factors intersect with chronic disease and influence pandemic resilience. The client sought evidence to clarify how exposures to contaminants in air, water, and soil contribute...
Read More about Environmental Health Factors, Chronic Diseases, and Pandemic Resilience

Food Inspection Scientific Analysis & Risk Modelling

In support of ongoing efforts to modernize Canada's food inspection system, a request was issued for scientific and analytical expertise to enhance two critical risk-based decision tools: the Establishment-based Risk Assessment (ERA) and Importer Risk Assessment (IRA) models. These models...
Read More about Food Inspection Scientific Analysis & Risk Modelling

Risk-based decision making framework

The Alliance of Blood Operators (ABO) sought to move its members toward a consistent, transparent approach to risk-based decision-making. Having worked through the development of a framework, the organization now wanted formal adoption, external validation, and practical application to real-world...
Read More about Risk-based decision making framework

Applying New Assessment Methods (NAMs) for Assessing Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds (SVOCs) in Indoor Residential Environments

Health Canada sought expert support in advancing its efforts to develop screening values for semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) commonly found in residential indoor environments. Previous work on indoor air contaminants had focused on volatile organic compounds (VOCs), where screening values...
Read More about Applying New Assessment Methods (NAMs) for Assessing Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds (SVOCs) in Indoor Residential Environments

International newspaper rethink

The International Herald Tribune (IHT) sought guidance at a time of profound change in the media landscape. With the World Wide Web emerging and competition intensifying from global and regional editions of established outlets such as The Economist, The Wall...
Read More about International newspaper rethink

Risk Communication on McIntyre Powder

In response to increasing public concern about the historical use of McIntyre Powder—an aluminum-based substance once administered to miners in Ontario to prevent silicosis—the client sought expert guidance on managing risk communication related to potential health implications. Widespread media coverage...
Read More about Risk Communication on McIntyre Powder