A Risk Sciences International Case Study

Risk Communication on McIntyre Powder

McIntyre Powder

Client: International Aluminium Institute

Listing of the client in no way affirms the client's support, sponsorship, or validation in any form of Risk Sciences International or the RSI staff member(s) who conducted this project during their stay with RSI or prior to joining the company. This case study is displayed for informative purposes only to demonstrate the capacity of RSI staff members. This case study reveals no proprietary information or information deemed sensitive.

Project description:

Risk Communication on McIntyre Powder

In response to increasing public concern about the historical use of McIntyre Powder—an aluminum-based substance once administered to miners in Ontario to prevent silicosis—the client sought expert guidance on managing risk communication related to potential health implications. Widespread media coverage and advocacy had raised public awareness and intensified scrutiny, particularly about possible links between aluminum exposure and long-term respiratory and neurological conditions.

The client aimed to develop a communication strategy to address fears that narratives around McIntyre Powder might extend to general concerns about aluminum exposure in everyday contexts. They required a scientifically grounded yet publicly accessible approach to contextualize the historic use of the substance while maintaining confidence in current aluminum safety standards.

To support these goals, RSI proposed and delivered a multi-phase risk communication initiative. The work began with validation of key issues highlighted in public discourse, followed by the development of a strategic communication plan tailored to defined audiences. Web-based materials were crafted to reflect the agreed-upon messaging, with client and expert reviews informing multiple revisions. A focus group session tested the clarity and resonance of the messages, ensuring alignment with audience perceptions.

In addition to finalized web materials, RSI developed internal communication tools, including talking points and Q&A documents, to help stakeholders respond consistently and effectively to inquiries. These materials underwent expert review to ensure both technical accuracy and communication effectiveness.

Start: 2018

End: 2018

Experts related to this case study

Anne Wiles

Senior Analyst

Dr. Anne Wiles joined Risk Sciences International (RSI) in 2008, where she currently serves as a Senior Analyst specializing in risk communication, perception, and governance. With a distinctive blend of expertise in language, regulation, and the use of science in...
Read More about Anne Wiles

Nataliya Karyakina

Senior Toxicologist, Health Risk Analyst

Dr. Nataliya Karyakina is a Senior Toxicologist and Health Risk Analyst at Risk Sciences International (RSI), where she has served since 2008. She plays a central role in RSI’s work at the intersection of chemical safety, regulatory science, and human...
Read More about Nataliya Karyakina

More RSI Case Studies

RSI presents a very small selection of case studies to highlight some of its key work.

Risk-Based Decision Making (RBDM) Compliance and Enforcement

Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED), through its Spectrum Management Innovation Directorate, sought support in applying risk-based decision making (RBDM) across its compliance and enforcement responsibilities. The department was looking for a structured and data-driven approach to prioritize regulatory...
Read More about Risk-Based Decision Making (RBDM) Compliance and Enforcement

Food safety risk analysis tools

The World Health Organization and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations asked RSI to develop a suite of online tools to support food regulators and the food industry in applying risk-based approaches to food safety. These organizations...
Read More about Food safety risk analysis tools

Systematic Review of Artificial Sweeteners and Health Risks

A comprehensive systematic review was undertaken to assess experimental evidence regarding the potential health risks associated with artificial sweeteners, specifically focusing on cancer and pre-term delivery. The client sought a rigorous analysis of both in vivo and in vitro experimental...
Read More about Systematic Review of Artificial Sweeteners and Health Risks

Expansion of the Stochastic Health Canada Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment Tool

Health Canada sought to enhance its Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment (QMRA) tool, originally developed over 15 years ago for stakeholders responsible for drinking water systems. With advancements in probabilistic modeling and microbial risk assessment, the client required updates to reflect...
Read More about Expansion of the Stochastic Health Canada Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment Tool

Analysis in Support of Risk-Based Decision-Making for the Alberta Safety Codes Council

An independent regulatory organization responsible for oversight of Alberta’s safety codes system sought to strengthen its capacity for risk-based decision-making. The organization aimed to ensure that regulatory actions—particularly in the area of petroleum storage tanks—were guided by clear, evidence-based prioritization...
Read More about Analysis in Support of Risk-Based Decision-Making for the Alberta Safety Codes Council

Evaluation of Health Product Risk Communication Tools

To enhance the effectiveness of health product risk communications, a systematic evaluation was requested to assess the performance of key instruments used to disseminate safety and efficacy information. The aim was to support efforts under the Evaluating the Effectiveness of...
Read More about Evaluation of Health Product Risk Communication Tools

Risk-Based Decision-Making (RBDM) Support for Plasma Supply / Sufficiency

Facing renewed challenges in securing a reliable domestic plasma supply, Canadian Blood Services sought support to apply a Risk-Based Decision-Making (RBDM) framework. The objective was to assess the value and implications of expanding domestic plasma collection and processing capacity in...
Read More about Risk-Based Decision-Making (RBDM) Support for Plasma Supply / Sufficiency

Characterizing uncertainty in MAF values estimated using the KEMI MAF

The client sought to improve understanding of uncertainties surrounding the application of mixture assessment factors (MAFs) for aquatic receptors, specifically those estimated using the KEMI methodology. While the KEMI MAF approach is considered technically robust, its assumptions—particularly about chemical-specific controls,...
Read More about Characterizing uncertainty in MAF values estimated using the KEMI MAF

Finalization of Risk Assessment on Secure Opioid Dispensing Devices

To support decision-making around modifications to opioid agonist treatment delivery, a detailed risk assessment was requested to evaluate the integration of secure dispensing devices for direct patient access to hydromorphone. Building on a previously conducted preliminary assessment, the work required...
Read More about Finalization of Risk Assessment on Secure Opioid Dispensing Devices

Wildfire and residential smoke risk communication

Government authorities faced recurring challenges in communicating health risks from smoke caused by both wildfires and residential burning. While these events were becoming more frequent and more severe, the public health messages often failed to resonate with affected communities or...
Read More about Wildfire and residential smoke risk communication

Development of a National Food Safety Information System and Risk Assessment Capacity in Vietnam

Authorities in Vietnam sought targeted expertise to strengthen the country’s ability to detect, assess, and respond to food safety threats. This initiative had two linked objectives: building a comprehensive, transparent, and reliable national food safety information system, and enhancing risk...
Read More about Development of a National Food Safety Information System and Risk Assessment Capacity in Vietnam

Risk Assessment of the Impact of Lethality Standards on Salmonellosis from Ready-to-Eat (RTE) Meat and Poultry Products

To support regulatory decision-making, a comprehensive risk assessment was conducted to evaluate how varying lethality performance standards would impact the public health burden of salmonellosis associated with Ready-to-Eat (RTE) meat and poultry products. The primary objective was to quantify the...
Read More about Risk Assessment of the Impact of Lethality Standards on Salmonellosis from Ready-to-Eat (RTE) Meat and Poultry Products

Applying New Assessment Methods (NAMs) for Assessing Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds (SVOCs) in Indoor Residential Environments

Health Canada sought expert support in advancing its efforts to develop screening values for semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) commonly found in residential indoor environments. Previous work on indoor air contaminants had focused on volatile organic compounds (VOCs), where screening values...
Read More about Applying New Assessment Methods (NAMs) for Assessing Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds (SVOCs) in Indoor Residential Environments

Validation and Optimization of the Computational Tool for the Microbial Risk Assessment Framework (MRAF)

To support more consistent and quantitative assessments of new micro-organisms under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, Health Canada's New Substances Program (NSP) sought to refine the tools and processes within its Microbial Risk Assessment Framework (MRAF). The NSP had previously...
Read More about Validation and Optimization of the Computational Tool for the Microbial Risk Assessment Framework (MRAF)

Communication material on lithium in drinking water and health risks

To support public communication around emerging drinking water concerns, RSI was engaged to develop accessible, scientifically grounded materials on lithium exposure and its potential health effects. The work focused on equipping stakeholders with clear, credible information that could inform both...
Read More about Communication material on lithium in drinking water and health risks

Airport traffic flow and signage review

An international airport authority sought a comprehensive assessment of passenger and vehicle traffic flow after receiving complaints of confusion and safety concerns. Reports indicated that passengers were struggling to interpret signage, often stopping too long to process graphics, which caused...
Read More about Airport traffic flow and signage review

Update of WHO Guidance on Food Defense

To support international efforts in mitigating deliberate threats to the food system, the World Health Organization commissioned an update to its earlier guidance titled Terrorist Threats to Food. The revision aimed to broaden the original scope by addressing not only...
Read More about Update of WHO Guidance on Food Defense

Evaluation of Drug Recall Communication and Risk Determination Processes

In response to public and ministerial concerns about the timeliness and adequacy of information shared during a major prescription drug recall, Health Canada commissioned an independent review to assess its response to the event. The situation involved a recall of...
Read More about Evaluation of Drug Recall Communication and Risk Determination Processes